Introduction:

If you own a home in Japan and are considering what to do with it—especially if it’s an older house, akiya (vacant property), or second home—you might be wondering: should I sell or rent my property?

The right choice depends on your financial goals, the condition of the property, its location, and how involved you want to be as a homeowner or landlord. This guide breaks down the pros and cons of selling vs. renting to help you make the best decision.

‍

‍

1. Selling Your Home in Japan: Pros & Cons

✅ Pros of Selling:

• Immediate cash flow – You get a lump sum you can reinvest or save.
• No ongoing maintenance – Once sold, you’re no longer responsible for repairs, taxes, or upkeep.
• Avoid property depreciation – Homes in Japan generally lose value over time, especially older homes.
• Easier process for owners abroad – No need to manage a property remotely.

❌ Cons of Selling:

• May not get the price you hoped for – Especially for akiya or rural homes, market demand can be low.
• Losing a long-term asset – If land value increases or tourism returns, you could miss out on future gains.
• Capital gains tax – If your property has appreciated in value, selling could trigger tax obligations.

Ideal for Sellers Who:

• Want to cash out and simplify their portfolio.
• Own a property in poor condition or in need of repairs.
• Live overseas and can’t manage property from afar.
• Have an akiya in a low-demand area.

2. Renting Out Your Home in Japan: Pros & Cons

✅ Pros of Renting:

• Ongoing income – Monthly rent can provide steady passive income.
• Keep the asset – You retain ownership of the property for future use or resale.
• Potential tax advantages – Expenses related to the rental may be deductible.
• Good option in high-demand areas – Urban homes and homes near stations tend to rent quickly.

❌ Cons of Renting:

• Property management responsibilities – Dealing with repairs, tenant issues, and inspections.
• Vacancy risk – Your home may sit empty between tenants.
• Wear and tear – The home may depreciate faster due to frequent use.
• Regulatory requirements – Rental properties must meet certain standards and reporting obligations.

Ideal for Owners Who:

• Want monthly cash flow and plan to hold the property long-term.
• Have a property in a rental-friendly location (near cities, schools, stations).
• Can manage (or outsource) landlord responsibilities.
• Aren’t ready to let go of the property.

3. Special Considerations for Akiya (Vacant Homes)

Many homeowners with akiya are unsure whether renting is even an option. Here’s what to consider:

Selling an Akiya:

✔ Easier if the home needs major repairs or is in a remote location.
✔ Platforms like Old Houses Japan help connect sellers with buyers who want fixer-uppers.
✔ Government grants may help buyers with renovation costs, increasing your chances of selling.

Renting an Akiya:

✔ May be possible if the home is in livable condition or renovated.
✔ Consider offering it as a long-term rental, guesthouse, or countryside retreat.
✔ Some owners convert akiya into monthly stays for digital nomads or domestic travelers.
✔ Rental yield may be lower in remote areas but higher if the home is unique or scenic.

4. Questions to Ask Yourself Before Deciding

• Do I need the money now or prefer ongoing income?
• Is the property in good condition, or does it require renovation?
• Do I want to deal with tenants and maintenance?
• Is the property in a location where it’s easy to rent or sell?
• Am I emotionally attached to the home, or ready to let it go?
• Am I living abroad or planning to return to Japan?

5. Final Thoughts: Sell or Rent? It Depends on Your Goals

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Selling might make sense if you want to simplify and walk away, while renting could be right if you’re looking for steady returns and future flexibility.

✔ If your home is old, hard to access, or needs repairs—selling is often the easier route.
✔ If the home is in a desirable area and in good shape—renting might offer better long-term benefits.
✔ If you’re unsure, consider talking to a real estate professional who understands the Japanese market.

At Old Houses Japan, we help homeowners evaluate their options and make informed decisions. Whether you want to list your home for sale or explore renting opportunities, we’re here to guide you. Book a call today and let’s explore what’s best for your property!