🏡 Airbnb vs. Long-Term Lease: Best Rental Strategy for Rural Homes

So you’ve bought (or are considering buying) an akiya in Japan. The house is yours, the renovations are underway, and now comes the big question:

👉 Should you rent it out on Airbnb (short-term) or as a long-term lease?

Both strategies have pros and cons—especially in the countryside, where demand patterns differ from Tokyo or Osaka. The best choice depends on your goals, the property itself, and the community around you.

Let’s break down the two approaches and help you decide.

‍

‍

🌐 Option 1: Airbnb (Short-Term Rentals)

Airbnb (or minpaku, as it’s called in Japan) is a popular choice for akiya investors, especially in tourist-friendly areas.

✅ Pros

• Higher nightly income: You can charge ¥8,000–¥25,000 per night depending on the property.
• Flexibility: Block off dates for your own use.
• Tourist appeal: Foreigners and urban Japanese love the novelty of staying in old homes with modern upgrades.
• Unique branding: Position your akiya as a “remote work retreat,” “traditional kominka stay,” or “eco-lodge.”

⚠️ Cons

• Strict regulations: Minpaku licenses are capped at 180 days/year in some areas. Others require full inn (旅館業 / ryokan-gyō) licenses.
• Seasonality: Summer, ski season, or festival times may sell out, but winters (in some areas) can be empty.
• Management costs: Cleaning, key handover, and guest communication add up unless you live nearby or hire a manager.
• Community sensitivity: Some rural towns dislike short-term rentals, especially if tourists disrupt quiet life.

💡 Best For: Properties near tourist draws (ski resorts, onsen towns, historic districts, beaches).

🏠 Option 2: Long-Term Lease

Long-term rental means leasing the home to a tenant—usually 1–2 years at a time under a standard Japanese rental contract.

✅ Pros

• Stable income: Monthly rent is predictable.
• Less turnover: Fewer management headaches.
• Community approval: Neighbors prefer stable residents over tourists.
• Easier with smaller towns: Some municipalities encourage long-term leases to attract new families.

⚠️ Cons

• Lower income potential: Rural rent is cheap—often ¥30,000–¥70,000 per month, no matter how nice your renovation is.
• Tenant protections: Eviction in Japan is extremely difficult if tenants stop paying.
• Less personal use: Once rented long-term, you can’t use the house for yourself.
• Limited demand in shrinking towns: Some rural areas simply don’t have people looking to rent.

💡 Best For: Homes in commuter towns near cities or in places with stable populations (university towns, regional hubs).

🧭 Hybrid Strategies: The Best of Both Worlds

Some akiya owners combine both models:

• Airbnb in peak seasons (summer, ski season, cherry blossom months).
• Mid-term leases (1–6 months) for digital nomads or city escapees in off-seasons.
• Renting a portion of the house long-term while keeping a wing or floor for short-term guests.

This hybrid approach maximizes ROI while smoothing out seasonal dips.

🏁 Final Thoughts

There’s no one-size-fits-all rental strategy for akiya.

• If your property is near tourism hotspots and you’re ready to handle (or outsource) management → Airbnb wins.
• If your goal is steady, passive income with less hassle → Long-term leasing makes sense.
• For many, the sweet spot is a hybrid model, balancing short-term high yields with mid- or long-term stability.

The key is knowing your location, goals, and community context.

🏡 Need Help Deciding on Your Rental Strategy?

At Old Houses Japan, we help akiya buyers run the numbers, navigate minpaku regulations, and connect with local property managers. Whether you want to run an Airbnb or secure long-term tenants, we’ll help you choose the best path.